Knowledge is Water

From Watergate to Downing Street, governments around the world operate on a need-to-know basis in which information is power and ignorance is bliss. This, it would seem, is a necessity for healthy governance, especially when information that could jeopardize national security is at hand. But sometimes, the definition of who, exactly, "needs" to know can call into question the structural integrity of this notion's entire foundation.

The assumption that one is entitled to information while others are not based upon some ambiguous measure of importance is like dumbbell curls of the ego muscles. And, what's more, it perpetuates the status quo of what I call knowledge elitism: I am better than you because I know more than you. Instead of basing exclusivity on geographic location, social status, or family connections, this paradigm establishes a hierarchy of importance based on the sole factor of access to information. And it is a cancer in our society.

Whether this desire to be counted among the knowledge elite stems from some nagging inferiority complex induced by schoolyard bullying or something entirely different, it does not matter. The end result is a system which treats information as a luxury, one reserved only for those who can afford it. Given this entrenched philosophy, it should come as no surprise that water is being bottled and sold for a dollar when it was once freely available in superior quality and quantity from the tap. Water, like knowing, has become a private commodity with varying degrees of access based on how much you are willing to spend.

But this system stands contrary to the desires of nature. According to the natural order, no one can claim ownership of water any more than purview over the stars in the heavens or dominion over the fish in the seas. So too goes for knowledge: it is a common resource, to be shared by, and implemented for the benefit of, the community. The more we lose sight of this truth, the more dire the consequences, because the severe deleterious effects a dearth of water access has on a community's health are analogous to those a lack of open access has on the pace of research. Every stumbling block retards the growth of science, resulting in far reaching consequences that present themselves in the long term.

In other words, knowledge is water. It's good for you and everyone needs it. So let's stop pretending that it's some exclusive commodity for the well-connected or well-paid. Because everyone knows the faucet only runs when it's open.

Nathan