PubMed Central and arXiv

PubMed Central (or PMC) is a digital archive of biomedical research that makes these papers freely available to the public. It is owned and operated by the U.S. National Institutes of Health and thus is a public resource.

PMC lends itself to comparison with arXiv: both are free digital archives of research papers helping advance the cause of OA. However, the differences abound. Firstly, PMC emphasizes the biomedical aspects of research while arXiv focuses upon the physical and quantitative sciences. Secondly, PMC is a resource funded by taxpayer dollars (through the NIH) but arXiv is operated by the private Cornell University.

Thirdly, papers are added to PMC by the journals that publish them; manuscripts are uploaded onto arXiv by the authors themselves. Finally, PMC ensures that the papers it archives have been subjected to thorough peer review (thus making Indexing by PMC a mark of validity). In contrast, arXiv does not impose any sort of review onto uploaded papers.

PMC and arXiv offer unique strengths and limitations and emphasize different fields of scientific endeavor. However, it appears clear that they are two very different approaches to the same ultimate goal: increasing access to scientific literature.

Nathan